Commercial surrogacy (advertising for a surrogate mother, and paying her for her services) is illegal in the UK.
The UK has what is commonly known as an ‘altruistic’ model of surrogacy, where a woman voluntarily undertakes a pregnancy for another couple or individual, and consents to give up her baby to them.
The woman may carry and give birth to a baby that is genetically hers, using her own egg, or may be inseminated with a fertilized embryo, using the egg of the commissioning mother, or another egg donor.
Currently, the surrogate mother, and her husband (if she has one) are listed as the baby’s parents at birth. The commissioning couple then have six months to apply to the Family Court to obtain a parental order, after which (if granted) they become the baby’s legal parents and a new birth certificate is issued.
The Law Commission are recommending:
- legal parentage moves from the surrogate mother at the point of granting the parental order, to the point of birth, meaning the birth mother is never listed as the mother of her own baby,
- they are also recommending a minimum of age of just 21 for surrogate mothers in the UK,
- reducing the time limit that a woman has to change her mind to just six weeks from delivery,
- allowing open advertisement for surrogate mothers in the UK
We believe this would lead to a commercial model of surrogacy in all but name in the UK. Already, surrogate mothers are often paid thousands of pounds in “expenses” during the course of the pregnancy, akin to a second salary, which incentivizes poor and vulnerable women to enter in to arrangements which leave them open to exploitation.
We have come across multiple cases of surrogate mothers regretting giving up their babies, and where parental orders have been successfully challenged and overturned. We believe the Law Commission’s proposals would make it harder for women to do this, and would turn the UK in to an international surrogacy destination.
Many people assume surrogacy in the UK takes place between friends and relatives. This is increasingly not the case: many parental orders are granted to parents who bring babies in from abroad, often conceived and carried through commercial surrogacy arrangements which are illegal here. And the ‘altruistic’ model sees strangers matched via surrogacy agencies, with many thousands of pounds changing hands: effectively buying babies off their mothers. Surrogacy, in all forms, is illegal throughout much of the world: in allowing surrogacy at all, the UK is an outlier. The proposals in this Bill would make this worse.
Some people claim that if a surrogate mother does not use her own egg in pregnancy then she is not related to her baby. But this is untrue. Her body nourishes and grows the baby for nine months: the environment in her uterus determines the biological development of the baby, and their cells interchangeably mingle. Pregnancy forges a lifelong bond between mother and child: this should never be broken, or denied.
It is time for a public debate on surrogacy in the UK. Join us.

Leave a Reply